| Ripe hip on R. carolina, on the Natchez Trace |
Although they are seedy and not very fleshy, hips are edible; in World War II in Britain, the hips were gathered for use as a vitamin C supplement. There are also many recipes for rose hip jam. Some amateur breeders have expressed interesting in selecting for hips for human consumption, but as far as I know little has come of this effort-- so for edible fruits from Rosaceae we'll have to stick to such staples as cherry, apple, pear, strawberry, peach, plum, et. al.
![]() |
| Hip on R. spinosissima repens at the National Arboretum |
As many roses hail from regions of the Northern Hemisphere with appreciable winter cold, the most common method for breaking the seed dormancy is stratification. Seeds can be left in the fridge for months, up to a year or two. Many will not germinate even when given this winter period, so pots of rose seeds should be kept for several years after sowing. The wearing off of natural germination inhibitors is also a factor.
![]() |
| Unripe hip on large flowered climber 'Stormy Weather,' at the National Cathedral Bishop's Garden |
Conventional wisdom dictates that seed be collected when the hips are ripe, but in practice it is possible to have equally good germination rates if the seed is collected slightly early. Once I was able to raise seedlings of Rosa rubiginosa from hips that were completely green-- so if you are in a pinch, late-season hips that aren't visibly ripe can still yield seedlings.
Here is the method that has worked best for me:
- Clean the seeds and wrap in a damp paper towels, wet with dilute Captan (fungicidal) solution; store in labeled ziploc bags
- Refrigerate for six months before checking the bags for any germinations; remove and pot seedlings as they appear
- Water the potted seedlings with dilute Captan
A major problem I've encountered is damping-off, with affects the base of the seedlings and causes them to rot. The fungicide Captan has proved to be an effective preventative. I have also read of a layer of perlite over the soil being used, as this reduces the moisture level around the seedling base where the fungus wreaks havoc. In my experience most commercial fine-texture seedling mixes work fine as long as they drain freely enough.
| Seedlings from repeating parents can bloom very quickly after germinating. |
Species or once-bloomer seedlings take years to grow before they bloom, but seedlings from reliably repeat-blooming parents bloom in the first year.
For the species, propagation via seed is preferred since each seedling will be genetically distinct. Seedlings of roses with complex pedigrees will usually be inferior to their parents and may exhibit significant visual differences-- the facet of mystery is what makes raising them so fun, even though the seedlings will likely only be of value to you.




